Best Eyeliner For Waterline

Best Eyeliner For Waterline In 2020

When talking about eyeliner, we usually think of the liquid version and how to make the perfect wing. But just as important for a dramatic look is to find the best eyeliner for your waterline. Seeing as how the waterline is a more sensitive and usually moist area, finding a suitable liner can be difficult.

Eyeliner Types

Us girls love to play with different looks, and eye makeup plays a big part in making the overall look as subtle or as emotive as we would like it. Different kinds of eyeliner are more useful in some cases than others, so here’s a quick play by play of what is out there to choose from:

Liquid Eyeliner

The most commonly used and most promoted, the liquid eyeliner offers a lot of options. The applicator is a delicate brush letting us paint on our lash-line. It gives us a very well defined and smooth look.

On the other hand, it does give us a lot of grief when we need to dabble with the symmetry of our wings. It is not the easiest thing to apply, andit may not be the best eyeliner for the waterline.

Pencil Eyeliner

When I was in my late teens and just beginning to use makeup, the pencil eyeliner paired with a bit of mascara and lip-balm was all I had up my sleeve.

A pencil liner makes it easy to apply exactly what you want. When applied to the waterline it makes for a very exciting look.

You need to always keep the tip clean and sharp for precise application. Also, you can always smudge it out to get a smokier look. This is probably the best eyeliner for the waterline.

Gel Eyeliner

A bit newer on the market, the gel liners are not very well represented in stores yet. They seem to be most useful in more professional environments rather than for individual users.

Makeup artists are more likely to make great use of these since gel liners make an amazing smokey eye and blend with ease.

What To Choose As The Best Eyeliner For waterline?

Since our main concern here is a waterline friendly eyeliner, the pencil liner is a solid choice. It comes in dark colors, but also in whites and nudes, which gives us many options.

You would be wise to stay away from liquid and gel liners when it comes to the waterline since they will very likely irritate your eyes.

Although, there are some liquid liners out there that are quick drying and waterproof, so if you’re careful with the application, you might pull it off.

Another way to irritate or even infect your eye is sharing makeup with others. Keep your makeup clean, and don’t share your liner pencil to avoid infection.

What Should You Be Looking For?

One of the traits I like to look for in an eyeliner pencil for my waterline is the softness.

A soft pencil is gentle to the membrane and lowers risk of irritation.Another trait that comes hand in hand with softness is the creaminess which makes it easier to blend and smear for a smoky look.

Alternatively, I don’t want to have to keep reapplying all day long. Therefore it’s endlessly useful to find a pencil liner that is waterproof.

You might also want to swatch them to check out how pigmented they are.Luckily, the pencil liners come in various colors, giving us a variety of choices for every occasion.

How To Use Eyeliner On Your Waterline?

The waterline is the inner membrane along our lower eyelid just above the lashline. The application of the pencil liner to the waterline might sound a bit scary at first, but I got used to it quickly and so will you.

Keep in mind that it has to be done with care and precision so don’t try to apply it while in a car or walking, and always use a mirror.

You will need to lightly pull down your lower lid to expose the waterline and gently apply the pencil liner until you’re satisfied with the coverage. Use white or nude color to make your eyes appear brighter or larger.

Otherwise, if you’re going for a bolder look, black is always an excellent choice. And if you want to take it up another notch, you can always add a thin layer of liquid eyeliner underneath your lower lash line.

Don’t forget always to pair eyeliner with mascara. Trust me; it ties everything together beautifully. There are many beauty vloggers out there, so if you need some inspiration in creating the perfect eyeliner look for yourself, you should check some of them out. That’s where I learned most of my makeup tricks.

Top 5 Eyeliners For Waterline

The market is full of various eyeliners which is great for us because it makes each brand try that much harder to stand out and offer us something we will love.

Using the general guidelines of which traits the best eyeliner for waterline should have, I’ve compiled a list of the top 5 eyeliners for the waterline currently out there.

bareMinerals, Long Lasting Eyeliner, Absolute black

The first contender for best eyeliner for waterline is a creamy, soft-textured liner which applies smoothly, which is always a good start. Apparently well pigmented, and is enriched with a blend of minerals and vitamin C.

It even comes with its little built-in sharpener. As promised in the name, it is long lasting, but if you’re after a very bold evening look, you might need to pile it on quite a bit. It comes in black, navy, brown and bronze. From what I’ve heard, it is quite gentle to the eyes and does not irritate.


  • Soft and smoothe
  • Hypoallergenic, mineral-enriched
  • No irritation
  • Long lasting


  • Weak color, has to be built upon
  • Smears on oily skin
  • Twist feature makes it difficult to apply
  • Difficult to remove

Kiss Me Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner, No. 1 Jet Black

A Japanese brand of eyeliner. It stands out for its claims to being sweat, tears and grease resistant. This claim is confirmed by a lot of consumers. It only comes in black, but the color is very strong and lasting.

The brush tip is very fine and allows precise strokes. I know I said that when it comes to the waterline, liquid liners are not the best for the job, but this one dries very quickly and after that, stays put.

So if you don’t have overly sensitive eyes, you could get away with it, since it is water resistant. Once it sets, the color is matte but if layered may get a tad more glossy. The packaging is adorable, so this would make a lovely gift as well.


  • Waterproof
  • Easy and precise application
  • Quick-dry
  • No irritation


  • Only comes in black
  • Not a lot of product in packaging
  • Not easy to remove
  • Pen dries quickly

COVERGIRL Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil Basic Black

This eyeliner pencil applies smoothly and comes with a plush blending tip. It can be easily smudged for a smoky eye effect. Sadly, it doesn’t seem to be very water or oil resistant.

On the other hand, it won’t smudge or migrate to the crease of your lid on its own. The application is easy, and you don’t need to go back and forth numerous times to get full coverage.

Moreover, it’s very well pigmented, and if left alone, will last all day. It will smear off onto clothes and pillows, so don’t forget to take it off at the end of the day. Given that it’s not waterproof, you can easily remove it by washing your face or using a wet wipe.


  • Well pigmented
  • Easy application
  • Great for smokey eye
  • Affordable


  • Not waterproof
  • Smudges
  • Must re-apply to waterline
  • Messy

Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Eyeliner Trio, Universal Looks Collection, Nude eyes

This is an eyeliner trio that offers a range of looks from nude to smokey. They are hypoallergenic and dermatologically tested, so they are quite safe for contact lense wearers and people with sensitive eyes.

It doesn’t smudge and is very waterproof. On the other hand, it is somewhat difficult to remove unless you have an oil-based makeup remover. It’s long lasting and not difficult to apply.

The ingredients are openly disclosed, and it is advertised as cruelty-free. The possible downside is that they are not sold individually and only come in three’s.

But you can always alternate between them for different looks, or give the ones you won’t use to someone as a gift. They have a somewhat glittery quality.


  • Hypoallergenic
  • Well pigmented
  • Waterproof
  • Smudge-proof


  • difficult to remove
  • not sold separately
  • doesn’t blend well
  • tricky application

L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Smoldering Eyeliner, Black

What differentiates this eyeliner pencil from others is the sharp conical shape meant for precise application. That is why it is sold with a customised sharpener to maintain the shape.

It is very well pigmented and blendable. Although smooth and easy to work with, it doesn’t seem to be waterproof so that it might need touch-ups during the day. Otherwise, it is long lasting, and won’t migrate to the crease of your eye if not smudged.

Unlike most pencil eyeliners, this one is not greasy and soft. The texture is a bit harder which allows it to keep the shape and not break during sharpening.

The most complaints about this product are the fact that it smudges and if you’re not careful and rub your eyes; you might end up with the so-called “raccoon eyes.”


  • Very pigmented
  • Lating
  • Specially shaped
  • Blends beautifully


  • Not waterproof
  • Smudges
  • Oily skin makes it melt
  • Not useful for wings


In my personal opinion, out of the five brands of eyeliners for the waterline, the Physicians Formula Shimmer Strips Custom Eye Enhancing Eyeliner Trio is the best eyeliner for the waterline.

The fact that it comes in three colors gives a nice variety of different looks. They can be combined or used on their own for very different styles, and I like that. I appreciate that they cover well most of the criteria for a good waterline eyeliner we spoke of.

They offer a good amount of pigment and blendability, while at the same time being waterproof and smudge-proof. I believe many people can also appreciate the hypoallergenic aspect of this product as well.

The drawbacks of this eyeliner pencil are easy to work around, making this hands down the best eyeliner for waterline out of the named. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top