Best Tingle Tanning Lotion In 2018
Tanning beds debuted as consumers followed the leads of celebs. Eventually, spray tanning salons became the only way to get a proper indoor tan that was more bronze than lobster red. Meanwhile, the cosmetics industry produced potions and lotions for home use.
When the tingle tan phenomenon dawned, consumer enthusiasm spiked, driven by consumers who lacked the patience it took to acquire a tan gradually. Tingle tanning products are fast and dramatic, appealing to the impatient crowd.
These days, tingle tanning is an art, science, and competition for companies eager to prove that their product delivers the most pain and gain. Even labels and bottles are wild and extreme. This is a whole new world of tanning.
What’s a Tingle Tan?
It's a stronger, deeper, faster way to tan that's produced by chemists mixing skin care ingredients with tanning agents and a chemical called methyl nicotinate.
Formulations are applied by hand, and from the moment lotion hits the skin, the reaction is a tingling or burning sensation accompanied by skin surfaces turning bright red. Degrees of red range from moderate to extreme. For those with sensitive skin, reactions are usually the most intense.
For tanners eager to see a dramatic difference immediately, tingle tan products are a heaven sent because they transform the skin from pale to tropical very quickly.
In fact, some are so reactive; the tingle can still be felt for days after application. Formulated for “seasoned” tanners, you can use it alone or in concert with a tanning bed to achieve bronze status.
According to Lotionsource.com, tingle tanning products first appeared on the market in the early 1990s, but this niche was so new and innovative, prices were sky high, and sales were sporadic.
The inventors of the earliest tingle tan lotions were chemists at John Abate International, an Arizona manufacturer that produced the first tingle products under the “Swedish Beauty” brand.
Word of this new lotion type spread fast, and formulations expanded from the first “Accelerator” to bottles labeled Tingle Levels 1, 2 and 3.
Ultimately, Tingle Factor 4 products were introduced, and with each iteration, mixtures became stronger and lasted longer, particularly when used in conjunction with tanning beds. Because these products aren’t regulated by the Food and Drug Administration, they are not subject to FDA testing, and there's no indication that this will change anytime soon.
Controversy surrounding tingle tanning products
It’s important to bring up the controversy surrounding tingle tanning products early in this review so you know what you could be getting into if your skin proves to be sensitive and reacts dramatically to the chemical agents used to make these products.
Additionally, the use of preservatives like Propylene Glycol and Butylene Glycol can compound that risk for users whose skin is hypersensitive. After all, everything you use on your skin eventually winds up in your bloodstream, so this is no insignificant lotion product given its ingredients.
TanPlusforHealth.com chemist Dan Bayer warns that ingredients responsible for producing the tingle can be so toxic, folks mixing and bottling them must wear masks “to prevent shortness of breath from working with these chemicals.” You may have no such reaction if your skin tolerates these agents, but a word to the wise: test tingle tanners on a small area of your skin before you cover your body to be on the safe side.
7 Tips and facts
1) Beware of jumping into a tingle tanner if you’ve never used a tanning product before. These products are formulated to accelerate the tanning process quickly and dramatically, so follow package instructions to the letter.
2) If you already have a lot of melanin in your DNA (you tan fast on your own after sunning or hitting the tanning bed) you may be lucky enough to skip the typical bright red reaction that other users with paler skin experience.
3) Expect to experience extreme tingling sensations as your skin accommodates itself to tingle tanning lotions. Depending on your system’s ability to tolerate the tingle, your skin may feel extremely hot for varying amounts of time.
4) Many tingle products contain bronzers. These boost the saturation of color even more intensely, so if you have fair skin and go all in on a product that’s designed to produce extreme results, you stand a better chance of bronzing.
5) While some women and men use tingle products on their faces, it’s not recommended by scientists or manufacturers. Package instructions and labels note that tingle tanners are recommended for extremities and the torso; not the face.
6) Don’t shower immediately after applying tingle tanning products or the formulation won’t have enough time to get into the bloodstream and begin transforming the skin.
7) Don’t handle kids or pets immediately after application. Some brand warnings recommend not touching either for several hours after application to be on the safe side. Because these products are powerful, clean your hands repeatedly after applying.
5 Best Tingle Tanning Lotion
Whether you’re a fan of the reality show or you wouldn’t watch it if your life depended upon it, the girls of Jersey Shore (2009 to 2012) have maintained their following by switching from acting wild on the beach on prime-time TV to being skin product entrepreneurs.
Jenni 'JWoww' Farley lends her name to one of the most highly-rated tingle products on today’s market. Pairing the tingle factor with bronzing agents--and bottled in an outrageously wild package--JWoww Mad Hot Tingle Bronzer doesn’t promise fame, but it could prepare you for the camera if you crave dramatically dark skin.
Produced by the company that started the tingle tan movement in the first place, the Pink Diamond T2 formulation includes a bronzer. It increases oxygen levels fast to produce darker and longer lasting color than earlier formulations and claims to tighten the skin and stimulate cell growth as well.
This lotion contains Carat Complex (caffeine and allantoin) and three moisturizers. Thus Swedish Beauty claims that Pink Diamond T2 Bronzer produces a “more moisturizing feel.” The citrus-cranberry fragrance is pleasing, but if all you want to do is look glam, this Swedish Beauty product should do the job at a more affordable price.
Once you get past the sticker shock and price of Ruby--and glimpse benefits and features it delivers, this could become your favorite tingle tanner.
The Ruby recipe includes a cooling agent to counteract redness and burning sensation all tingle tanners produce, so despite intensity, you could feel more comfortable after applying this formula.
Ingredients are exotic: spicy fruit of Capsaicin and licorice extract are just two worth mentioning. Ruby tingle tanner lotion is advertised as having a 19X bronzing capacity, so if numbers impress you, you may not mind taking out your plastic to try it.
The Ed Hardy brand is associated with a wide variety of lotions and potions, so it stands to reason chemists producing it stand behind that Extreme claim.
Develop a base tan in a week using this lotion, at which point; the color should stick around for a long time if you administer “boosters” a few days a week.
Some say it’s the most intense of all formulations on today’s market, with more users calling the sensation hot over warm. Not for the novice tanner, this product lives up to its extreme label.
Having become acclimated to words used to describe today’s tingle tanners, you won’t be surprised to see the words XS Mega Extreme XXX Sizzling associated with this Devoted Creations Trinity tingle tanner.
Formulated with anti-aging and firming ingredients, it includes black bronzing silicone and Matrixyl Synthe 6 additives that are said to put the XXX in the tingle. The one-time application delivers an immediate tan, though not every purchaser raves about this product’s fragrance.
It can be difficult to wade through hyperbole associated with these products because manufacturers employ just about every exclamation-worthy term in the dictionary to assert their product’s superiority.
That stated, remove the wild packaging and names from the equation, and in our opinion, Pink Diamond® T2 Tingle Bronzer by Swedish Beauty makes the most sense for all types of tanners: new, seasoned and tanning bed fans.
It’s been around the longest, the price point is manageable, it's widely available, and it's the only product that is formulated with anti-sagging and cell growth ingredients. Buying a product that’s an industry pioneer is always a good bet if you’re new to tingle tanning.
Keep in mind the fact that Pink Diamond may offer more benefits than competitors and at a better price, but like competitor products, it is not FDA approved, so apply with care and remember to test a section of skin to see how it will react before you cover your body with it. If you love the results, go forth and be a bronze god or goddess via the company that pioneered this product line in the first place!